Coffee knowledge

Specialty coffee: what it is and how to recognise it

Colombian coffee plantation in Quindío, Garza Coffee

I grew up in Valle del Cauca, Colombia, surrounded by coffee fields. For me, specialty coffee is not a marketing category. On this page I explain what the industry means by it and how we work with it at Garza Coffee.
— Juan García, Garza Coffee

Specialty coffee is not a marketing label. The category has been defined within the industry for decades. To carry the name, a coffee must reach a sensory score of 80 points or more under the Specialty Coffee Association standard, be free of primary defects and have a traceable origin.

This page explains what that means exactly, how a coffee is scored, how to recognise specialty coffee in everyday life and how we at Garza Coffee work with producers in Colombia.


Definition

What is specialty coffee? The SCA definition

The term specialty coffee was coined in 1974 by Erna Knutsen in the USA. Today's Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) was formed in 2017 from the merger of the American SCAA (founded 1982) and the European SCAE (founded 1998). The SCA defines the standard by which specialty coffee is evaluated worldwide.

Three criteria must be met:

1. A sensory score of 80 to 100 points

The evaluation is carried out by a Q Grader, a sensory expert certified by the Coffee Quality Institute. Ten sensory attributes are scored, each on a scale of up to 10 points: dry and wet aroma, flavour, aftertaste, acidity, body, balance, sweetness, uniformity, clean cup and overall. Defects are recorded separately and deducted from the total score. Only from 80 points does a coffee count as specialty.

2. No primary defects in the green coffee

A 350 gram sample of green coffee must contain no primary defects: no fully black or sour beans, no mould, no foreign matter. A small number of secondary defects is allowed.

3. Full traceability

Producer, farm, region, variety, processing method and harvest year must be documented. Without this information there is no specialty coffee, because quality and story belong together.


Comparison

Specialty coffee vs. commodity coffee

Most of the coffee traded worldwide is commodity coffee. It is traded on the New York exchange, blended across origins and qualities, roasted in large volumes and sold from supermarket shelves over months or years. Specialty coffee follows a completely different logic.

FeatureSpecialty coffeeCommodity coffee
Score (SCA)80 to 100 pointsbelow 80 points
Origintraceable to the farmblend of anonymous sources
Producer pricewell above the exchange priceexchange price, often below production costs
Processingcareful, small batchesindustrial, large volumes
Roastingsmall, fresh, matched to the beanlarge, long storage possible
Freshnessweeks to a few months after roastingup to two years on the shelf
Flavour profilecomplex, diverse, variety-specificuniform, often bitter

Evaluation

How is specialty coffee evaluated? The cupping process

Hand holding a coffee cherry, manual selection of cherries, Colombia

Cupping is the SCA's standardised method for evaluating coffee by taste and aroma. It follows fixed rules so that Q Graders around the world arrive at comparable results.

The procedure: twelve grams of coarsely ground coffee are placed in a bowl and brewed with 200 millilitres of water at 93 °C. After four minutes the crust is broken and the Q Grader evaluates first the fragrance, then the aroma in the cup. Once the coffee has cooled to around 70 °C, it is tasted from a special spoon in shallow slurps.

Each of the ten attributes receives up to 10 points. Defects are recorded separately and deducted from the total score.

Within the specialty class (80 to 100 points) there are clear differences in quality. At Garza Coffee the coffees range from 83 to 88 points, with most between 86 and 87. The highest in the current range is Spice Cosmic with 88 points, winner of the Café Exótico category at the Roasted Coffee Champions Quindío 2025. The score is shown on every product page.


At origin

Directly with the producers

We buy directly from the producers, with no intermediaries. These pictures were taken during our visits to the farms in Colombia.

Juan Puerta at Finca La Sirena, Quindío, Colombia
Juan Puerta at Finca La Sirena, Quindío.
Juan García of Garza Coffee with Alejandro Gil at Finca Bellavista, Caldas
With Alejandro Gil at Finca Bellavista, Caldas.

Why specialty coffee?

What matters for you

Flavour

Specialty coffee shows aromas that do not occur in commodity coffee. The bean delivers notes of berries, stone fruit, cocoa, honey, blossom or citrus. Not because anything was added, but because the variety, the climate and the processing bring out these aromas. A good specialty coffee tastes of the place where it grew.

How to recognise a truly high-quality specialty coffee in everyday life, what to look for on the bag and which details transparent producers disclose, is something I have explained in detail in this article.

Freshness

Coffee loses aroma from the roast date onwards. With commodity coffee there is often a year between roasting and drinking. Specialty coffee is roasted in small batches and ideally consumed within a few weeks of roasting. At Garza Coffee we roast weekly and ship straight after roasting.

Fair pay for producers

The exchange price for coffee is regularly below production costs in the growing countries. Specialty coffee is traded at prices that can be several times higher. That is linked to quality, but also to the direct relationship between roaster and producer.

Transparency

Every one of our product pages states where the coffee comes from: producer, farm, region, altitude, variety, processing, score. If you want to know what you are drinking, you can trace it.


Producers

Directly from named producers

We work exclusively with named Colombian producers whom we visit in person: Juan and Geraldine Puerta (Sens Coffee, Finca La Sirena, Quindío), Alejandro Gil (Finca Bellavista, Caldas), Edinson Argote (Quebraditas Coffee Farm, Huila), the Zuluaga family (Finca La Isabela, Quindío) and Edwin Noreña (Campo Hermoso, Circasia, Quindío).

Each producer brings their own approach, from classic processing with the Castillo variety to experimental co-fermentations with osmotic dehydration and hop fermentation.

The full story of each producer, the regions of Colombia and the varieties we roast is something I have explained in this article on specialty coffee from Colombia.


Our approach

How Garza Coffee does specialty coffee

Garza Coffee at the Frankfurt Coffee Festival, stand with Colombian specialty coffees
Our stand at the Frankfurt Coffee Festival, Röster Revier.

Garza Coffee is a small roastery in Berlin, specialised in Colombian specialty coffee. We buy directly from the producers and roast fresh every week.

Our range sits between 83 and 88 SCA points, with washed, honey process, natural, carbonic maceration and experimental co-fermentation lots. Some coffees are designed as omni roasts and therefore work for both espresso and filter.


FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What exactly does specialty coffee mean?+

A coffee that scores at least 80 out of 100 points in the Specialty Coffee Association evaluation, is free of primary defects and has a fully traceable origin. All three criteria must be met together.

How does specialty coffee differ from regular coffee?+

In score, in origin and in pricing. Regular coffee is traded on the exchange and comes from large blended lots. Specialty coffee comes from a specific farm, from a specific producer, with documented processing. Producers receive a price well above the exchange price.

Why is specialty coffee more expensive?+

For several reasons. Production costs more: smaller batches, more careful processing, longer drying times. The producer receives a fair price instead of the exchange price. Roasting is small-scale and fresh instead of industrial and stored. The higher price reflects the quality and the relationship with the producers.

Is specialty coffee healthier?+

Not automatically, but it contains no primary defects such as mouldy or sour-fermented beans, which can occur in commodity coffee. It is also fresher, which preserves antioxidant compounds better.

How long does specialty coffee keep?+

Roasted, unopened and stored cool, it keeps its aroma at its best for about four to six weeks, after which it slowly declines. Once opened, it should be used within two to three weeks. By comparison, industrial supermarket coffee often sits on the shelf for more than a year.

Which processing method is the best?+

None is objectively better, it comes down to taste. Washed gives clear, clean aromas with higher acidity. Honey keeps some sweetness from the fruit pulp. Natural brings intense, fruity notes. Co-fermentations such as Apricot OD or Tropical Lulo create completely new aroma profiles that would not be possible with classic processing.

What is co-fermented coffee?+

An experimental method in which additional ingredients are added to the coffee during fermentation, for example fruit (apricot, lulo, coffee blossom), yeasts or hops. The aromas from these ingredients pass into the bean. More on this in our article on co-fermented coffee.

Can I buy specialty coffee online?+

Yes. We ship directly from our Berlin roastery, freshly roasted, throughout Germany. Free shipping on orders from 50 euros.

Which specialty coffees does Garza Coffee offer?+

Currently twelve single-origin specialty coffees from Colombia, with scores between 83 and 88. The full overview is in our filter coffee collection and in the espresso section.


Range

Our current specialty coffees


For cafés, hotels & offices

Specialty coffee for business

Do you run a café or restaurant, a hotel, or are you responsible for the coffee supply in your office? We deliver our Colombian microlots directly from our Berlin roastery: freshly roasted, with advice at your machine and terms that fit your needs.


Dive deeper

Further reading